How to check tea before buying
No single home test can check tea for authenticity before buying. Fraud is when the ingredients, origin, age or producer differ from what was claimed. A flavoured tea that is clearly labelled is no counterfeit, and a tea you dislike may be perfectly genuine.
An example of a paper wrapper for sheng pu-erh.
Photo: Ash Crow · CC BY-SA 4.0Pin down the specific claim
Save the listing. Then ask what supports the details you care about, be it region, year, cultivar or the absence of additives. With factory pu-erh, ask for photographs of the packaging and for batch information. Where the producer offers authentication, go through its official website or support team. Security features change from year to year and product to product, so a random photograph found online is no reference for every release.
Do not count infusions to spot flavouring
Tea can smell intensely floral or fruity with nothing added. How long that lasts comes down to the tea, its storage and the brewing, and an aroma that drops away sharply after two or three infusions proves nothing about flavouring. Jasmine tea is traditionally scented with fresh flowers. “Milk oolong” may describe naturally creamy notes or an added flavour, so read the ingredients. Additives are a problem when they are concealed, and only then.
Do not judge a pu-erh’s age by colour
Dark leaves, old paper, a smooth taste and ten infusions tell you nothing certain about age. Storage in a more humid climate does not make a tea fraudulent. The questions are whether the stated history is accurate and whether the tea is in sound condition, so ask where the batch came from and how it was stored. Do not taste tea that shows suspicious growth, is damp or smells clearly of mould. Rinsing will not make it safe.
What the brewed leaves can tell you
Brewed leaves show you size, buds, stems, breakage and how much the sample varies. They cannot reliably identify a village, the age of the trees, hand picking or a claimed cultivar. A blend only deceives when it is sold as something else. Some oolongs have no visible red rim, Tieguanyin can be roasted, and a strong roast on Da Hong Pao is no sign of a fake either.
If you have doubts about a purchase
Photograph the packaging, the batch number and the problem itself, and hold on to the receipt and any correspondence. Ask the seller to explain the particular discrepancy. If that gets you nowhere, contact the producer or use the shop’s returns process. A taste you find unpleasant settles nothing about origin. And if bitterness is the only complaint, with no sign of spoilage, try less leaf or a shorter infusion first.
Questions and answers
Can a lab test prove which region a tea is from?
Only up to a point. Some methods compare samples against validated reference data, but no universal test can name the village and the age of the tree from any cup of tea. As a buyer you will get further by asking where that batch came from and how it reached the seller.
Does a high price protect against fake tea?
No. Neither the price, nor a familiar logo, nor a stated plantation elevation can stand in for checking the seller and the product. If you are paying extra for a rare origin, ask for the evidence before you buy.
Related teas
See also
Chinese tea guides