To taste tea for the first time you need teaware you know, clean water and a few minutes in which the tea has your full attention. Look at the leaves, let the infusion cool until it is comfortable to drink, and note what you taste. If your impressions differ from the seller’s tasting notes, that is allowed.
Choose one or two teas
Pick a single tea, or two similar ones to set side by side, two Chinese black teas for instance. Matching mugs with infusers will do, and so will teapots or gaiwans. Use the same water for both and write down leaf weight, water volume, temperature and time. The brewing advice for that tea is the place to start.
Similar teas should be compared under like conditions. Teas of different styles can each be brewed as recommended, provided you remember that the recipe shapes the result too. Keep strong smells out of the room, and after strongly flavoured food wait until the taste has faded.
Look at and smell the dry leaves
Look at size, shape and colour, and at the buds and stems. All of it hints at the material and the processing. Still, whole leaves do not always beat cut ones, and pale leaves are no better than dark by default.
Now smell a small portion. Warming it in a preheated vessel that has been wiped dry can make the aroma easier to catch, if you want to go that far. Begin with broad categories: floral, fruity, grassy or roasted. Mould, signs of damp damage or a suspicious musty smell mean you do not taste the tea to check it.
Taste a small sip, then pause
When the brewing time is up, separate the infusion from the leaves. Let a small amount cool until it is comfortable, then sip. You can slurp gently if you like, but never draw scalding tea into your mouth.
Flavour comes first: sweetness, bitterness, acidity or umami, where they are present. Mouthfeel is next. Is the tea light or full, smooth or astringent, drying or not? After you swallow, wait, and notice which flavours stay and how they change. A sweet finish that returns is called hui gan, and it need not follow bitterness in a fixed sequence.
Follow how the tea changes
Go back to the same cup as it cools and taste it again. Then compare the first few infusions and watch how aroma, strength and astringency shift. Each one may bring out a different part of the tea.
A tea that is too strong wants a shorter steep or fewer leaves next time. Change one thing only and note what happens. Stop when you have had enough, or if you feel unwell.
Examine the infused leaves
Spread a few leaves on a pale plate. Can you see buds, mature leaves, stems or cut pieces? Rolled leaves often open into shapes that were hard to make out when dry.
Bear the type of tea in mind, since ripe pu-erh and Longjing will never look alike. Colour, flexibility and size prove nothing about safety, tree age or authenticity. Compare the aroma of the wet leaves with the infusion, and do not treat either one as the only reliable evidence.
Keep a note you can use later
A few lines will do: “Dian Hong, 2.5 g / 250 ml, 95 °C, 3 minutes. Dried-fruit aroma, mild bitterness, slightly drying. Try 2 minutes next time.” That is an example of a note and should not be read as a universal recipe.
Write down your own impressions before you read anyone else’s. “Creamy” might describe the aroma or the texture, and you may find neither. By all means check the batch and the brewing method, but a different impression does not mean your palate is wrong.
Yes. A mug with a roomy infuser lets you control the steeping time and makes comparing teas easy. Short infusions in a gaiwan are another way to explore the flavour.
Only if scores help you. A note on the flavour, how you brewed it and whether you would drink it again is usually enough to guide the next purchase.