To choose your first pu-erh, start with two or three samples that taste different from one another. Get a ripe pu-erh and a young raw one, and if you are curious, an aged raw tea whose storage history is documented. Nobody has to learn to drink ripe tea before moving on to raw.
Decide what flavours to try
Ripe pu-erh goes through wet piling, or wo dui. It usually brews dark and tastes woody, nutty or earthy. Young raw pu-erh is often more floral, grassy or fruity, and its bitterness and astringency are easy to notice. These are broad tendencies only. Brew a ripe tea strongly and it can turn bitter, while a young raw tea can be gentle.
Buy enough to try it more than once
A sample of 15–25 g is enough for several sessions, with room to adjust how you brew. You learn more from comparing samples than from committing to a large cake at the outset. Loose tea, cakes, bricks and tuo are formats and say nothing about quality. Weights vary as well. Not every cake weighs 357 g, and a mini tuo is not necessarily the right serving for your vessel.
Check the description and the price
The description should name the producer or supplier, say whether the tea is raw or ripe, and give the batch, along with the harvest and pressing dates where those differ. With an aged tea, ask where and how it was stored. Village names, gu shu claims and tree ages need evidence behind them, and neither flavour nor leaf size can supply it. Compare prices for the same weight, delivery included. No universal price exists below which all pu-erh is fake, or above which it is good.
Look it over before brewing
Stems and broken leaves can be a normal part of a blend, and a lot of buds is no guarantee of better flavour. Foreign debris, dampness, suspicious growth or a musty smell are all grounds for rejecting a sample. A white fuzzy coating is not harmless just because it is white. Never taste suspect tea, and do not try to rescue it by rinsing.
Compare in the cup
A first trial in a gaiwan takes 4 g per 100–120 ml, with water at 90–95 °C for young raw tea or 95–100 °C for ripe and aged raw tea. Give it 10–15 seconds, counted from the start of the pour, and drain fully. That is only a starting point, since a tightly compressed piece may open more slowly. If the tea is bitter, shorten the infusion or use less leaf and try again. Judge by the aroma, flavour and aftertaste you enjoy. A tea does not have to last eight infusions or deliver instant returning sweetness. Write down the batch, the price and how you brewed it.
No particular age is required. Both raw and ripe pu-erh can be enjoyed young. Ageing changes a tea, but it guarantees no improvement and cannot undo poor storage.
Only if it interests you, and then as a small sample from a seller who explains where the tea comes from and how it was stored. A full cake can wait until you have had several enjoyable sessions and know what you are paying for.